The San Diego Community College District last week stood by its decision to have author Alice Walker as the keynote speaker at the district’s investiture celebration May 31, an event in which the district formally confers power on its new chancellor, Carlos Cortez.

Walker, author of “The Color Purple,” was recently dropped from participating in the Bay Area Book Festival because of her support for David Icke, a writer whose work she has promoted regularly despite those works advancing antisemitism and conspiracy theories.

For example, Icke has pushed conspiracy theories around COVID-19, spreading misinformation about the virus and even suggesting a Jewish group had been involved with its spread, according to the BBC.

As Vox Media noted in its thorough breakdown of Walker and Icke’s relationship, Icke has also incorporated a wide variety of antisemitic conspiracy theories in his work suggesting Jewish people financed the Holocaust, were behind the slave trade, and are pulling the strings for racist groups, like the Ku Klux Klan.

Despite the actions of other organizations and receiving criticism from some in San Diego’s Jewish community, the district defended its decision. It told the U-T’s Gary Robbins that Walker is a source of inspiration for many in the community — including Cortez — and the decision does not mean it agrees with every statement she has made.

"(She) is a Pulitzer Prize-winning author and her participation is consistent with the District’s support of the free exchange of ideas and opinions,” the district said.

There is a lot to unpack here about Walker and Icke, but let’s start with that explanation from SDCC because it relies on a cop-out people lean on far too often when confronted by hateful speech.

This isn’t about a free exchange of ideas or someone trying to “silence” some part of a conversation. This is about reckless rhetoric and whose voices we choose to elevate in a conversation.

There is no doubt that Walker has contributed mightily to literature, just as she has undeniably forged an impressive record advocating for social justice going back to her early days working for the New York Department of Welfare and the NAACP Legal Defense Fund.

However, that doesn’t mean we refuse to look at the entire person, and it doesn’t absolve her of the dangerous ideas she has chosen to promote.

Icke is not someone who should be admired or have his work promoted because he traffics in absurd conspiracy theories and his work is unapologetically antisemitic. The fact that Walker chooses to use her platform and well-earned cultural cache to promote him is disturbing.

Even setting Icke aside though, it is problematic for SDCC to turn a blind eye to Walker’s own words and essentially honor her with the unchallenged platform that comes with being a keynote speaker.

As writers like Nylah Burton and Yair Rosenberg have noted, Walker herself has directly espoused antisemitic rhetoric. Among other things, Walker published a poem on her blog in 2017 called “To Study the Talmud,” in reference to a book of Jewish law that is often quoted out of context by extremists to attribute a litany of ills to Jews.

For example, Walker uses her poem to claim the ancient text condones pedophilia and the murder and the enslavement of non-Jews.

Those kind of views go beyond simply exchanging ideas or differences of opinion. They’re hateful and dangerous, and community leaders like Cortez and SDCC have a moral obligation to not allow those views to go unchallenged.

Preventing someone from having an unchallenged platform is not canceling someone, and that is one of the fundamental issues with SDCC’s choice here.

In an event like a book festival, which I actually think should have kept Walker’s panel, a person is typically forced to engage in a give-and-take with a moderator and audience members during which a person faces a degree of accountability for their views.

In an event like a keynote address, though, there typically is none of that. Someone like Walker is given a position of honor, as well as the opportunity to share whatever they want unchallenged, all while never having to answer for past actions.

I’m not sure what values or culture Cortez and SDCC think they’re creating by bestowing someone like Walker with the honor of that platform. It sends a disheartening message to members of our Jewish community, and I’d argue it calls into question how seriously leadership takes bigotry in other forms.

Compounding all of this is also Walker’s refusal to acknowledge Icke for what he is, and her refusal to acknowledge the validity of some of the criticisms that have been directed at her. She has hidden behind the guise that this has to do with her advocating for Palestine, which is asinine.

Walker has long criticized the Israeli government and its behavior toward Palestinians. There is nothing wrong with some of those criticisms, just as there’s nothing wrong with criticizing any other government. But there is a difference between saying the Israeli government treats the rights of Palestinians differently than the rights of other citizens, and promoting conspiracy theories like a cabal of Jewish people are running everything or Holocaust denial.

Walker should know that. And the fact that she doesn’t or is intentionally ignoring it should disqualify her from being given this honor and an unchallenged platform.

I sincerely hope that Cortez and SDCC re-evaluate the decision or at a bare minimum provide a much more thorough and thoughtful explanation for why they are standing by Walker. Because this is a weird message to send to the community early in your tenure.

Get Essential San Diego, weekday mornings

Get top headlines from the Union-Tribune in your inbox weekday mornings, including top news, local, sports, business, entertainment and opinion.

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the San Diego Union-Tribune.

Column: “Beating a dead horse,” and why we cannot wait for a new sheriff to spur action in county jails

Column: Phounsy verdict shows problems of accountability and in-custody deaths go beyond Sheriff’s Dept.

Column: Bias, retaliation and the importance of ignorance v. malevolence in the San Dieguito Union chaos

Column: Rancho Bernardo nail salon labor case underscores the dangers facing some immigrant workers

Column: Sadly, East County’s rep for intolerance is well-earned and goes beyond isolated incidents

Column: With jail deaths mounting in San Diego County, it’s time for the federal government to intervene

Column: Hulu’s adaptation of Sally Rooney’s ‘Conversation With Friends’ leaves many things unsaid

Newcomer Alison Oliver stars in ‘Conversations with Friends,’ a low-simmering adaptation of Sally Rooney’s percolating novel

Column: Alvarez-Gómez race is a microcosm of California politics — and a whole lot more

The Assembly contest between two prominent Democrats is rife with intrigue, including surprise GOP spending against Gómez

Column: Leucadia filmmaker Ron Ranson’s ‘Tattooed Trucks of Nepal’ is an award-winning ride

UC San Diego’s Ron Ranson documents Nepal’s arty trucks in the award-winning documentary ‘Tattooed Trucks of Nepal - Horn Please’

Column: Revolutionary service starts at two S.D. commissaries — delivery

Miramar and Naval Base San Diego to show they really deliver -- groceries, that is

Column: Padres starter MacKenzie Gore says uncertain situation ‘much bigger than me’

Joe Musgrove counsels young arm as rotation depth balloons like never before

Column: S.D. police union’s sharp words for Montgomery Steppe draw rebukes from council members, mayor

San Diego Police Officers Association’s new leadership takes aggressive posture amid budget deliberations and a push to curtail pretext stops of motorists and people on the street

Mortgage rates are up. Here’s what it could mean for San Diego’s home market

Meet the candidates for San Diego County Sheriff

How to watch Padres’ weekend games on Apple TV+, Peacock

How a Del Mar fairgrounds vendor landed a no-bid contract extension in exchange for a $2M loan

Transfer Micah Parrish from Detroit is latest example of Aztecs’ expanding recruiting radius

From the Archives: The San Diego Zoo’s Safari Park opened 50 years ago

From the Archives: 39 arrested in Vietnam War protest in Del Mar in 1972

San Diego accelerating cannabis equity program, proposing increase in number of dispensaries

Pandemic policy that set bail at $0 for many crimes is going away Sunday

Padres notes: Lamet to Triple-A; Gore remains; Melvin shoots for S.F. return

Privacy Policy Terms of Service Sign Up For Our Newsletters